Since Common Core testing this past spring, I have spoken with dozens of Education/Resource Specialists throughout the state about their students’ experiences taking the SBAC or CAA. Over and over I’ve heard stories of frustration, anger, and tears from both the students and the teachers. Educators keep asking: Why do our students have to take a test that is so wildly inappropriate for them? The truth is, they don’t have to take the test. Their parents can opt them out of taking this test (and others) BUT ONLY IF THEY KNOW IT IS THEIR RIGHT.
After November’s Rep Council unanimously passed the resolution I wrote to push back on the District’s unhealthy fixation on interim assessments, I realized that SDEA membership is ready to start speaking up about the negative impact Common Core testing is having on our students and instruction. After conferring with Special Ed teachers, I wrote this resolution and brought it to December’s Rep Council. While I had hoped that we reps, as the democratically elected decision-making body of our union, could amend the resolution and pass it in December, a substitute motion by Ramon Espinal, seconded by Bill Freeman, to make it a first read passed so that the resolution could be sent to the CTA legal department for feedback and be brought back to the January Rep Council this month.
So far, I have not been impressed with the CTA staff’s overly cautious position that seems to follow the logic that notifying parents of their rights could be misconstrued as advocating for parents to opt out, which is currently a violation of California Ed Code. Personally, I and hundreds of other CTA delegates are hoping that the CTA staff and its legal department will remember why they exist: To advocate for the educational rights of the children of California and to protect them from unfair and unjust laws.
CTA legal’s opinion was reported back to us at the January Rep Council: They could find nothing technical to object to, but believed we would be in legally uncharted territory. To which I responded on the Rep Council floor, “So let’s chart it!” I am excited that SDEA’s ARs and CRs voted unanimously to pass the resolution and is presenting it at the January 26th school board meeting.
SDEA Resolution For Parental Notification
by Resource/Education Specialists of Right to Opt Out
WHEREAS, San Diego Education Association (SDEA) previously passed the Resolution Against High Stakes Testing; and
WHEREAS, the San Diego Unified School District (SDUSD) Board unanimously passed a resolution on February 10, 2015, that calls on the U.S. Congress and Obama Administration to “eliminate the federally-mandated, annual testing requirement in each of Grades 3 through 9, and at least once in Grades 9 through 12; promote multiple forms of evidence of student learning and school quality in accountability; and not mandate any fixed role for the use of student test scores in evaluating educators”; and
WHEREAS, Superintendent Cindy Marten sent a letter home to parents in April 2015 before the SBAC was administered which included information about the parental right to opt out their child from testing; and
WHEREAS, students in the Mild to Moderate program are administered the SBAC, and students in the Moderate to Severe program are administered the CAA; and
WHEREAS, many students in the Moderate to Severe program do not have the mobility skills necessary to take the CAA; and
WHEREAS, the SBAC/CAA is grossly developmentally inappropriate for many students with special needs; and
WHEREAS, many students are subjected to unnecessary mental and emotional stress and duress during the administration of the SBAC/CAA; and
WHEREAS, the SBAC/CAA does not assess students according to the curriculum and learning goals specified in the student’s Individualized Education Plan (IEP); and
WHEREAS, students in Applied Math and English classes have significant learning disabilities that preclude them from accessing grade level curriculum; and
WHEREAS, students in Applied Math and English classes are expected to take the same SBAC as students in general education classes, even though their curriculum does not align with this assessment; and
WHEREAS, the data collected from many students with special needs by administering the SBAC is not useful in creating curriculum or IEP learning goals for students; and
WHEREAS, no school has ever lost Federal funding for testing less than 95% of all student populations; and
WHEREAS, test scores have been used as justification for closing down or reorganizing public schools; and
WHEREAS, most educators would not administer the SBAC/CAA to many students with Mild to Moderate or Moderate to Severe disabilities if given a choice for reasons aforementioned; and
WHEREAS, parents and guardians are unable to exercise legal rights if they do not know they have them; and
WHEREAS, an educator notifying and educating parents of students with special needs about their right to opt out their child from testing is not the same as encouraging the parent or guardian to opt out their child from SBAC/CAA and other testing;
RESOLVED that SDEA call on SDUSD to make it common practice that all Resource Teachers and Education Specialists notify and educate the parents and guardians of students with an IEP of their right to opt out their child from SBAC/CAA and all other applicable testing; and
RESOLVED that SDEA call on SDUSD to add to the existing IEP signature page a check box that indicates that the parents have received information about their ability to opt out their child from SBAC/CAA and other applicable testing; and
RESOLVED that SDEA call on SDUSD to honor parents choosing to opt out their children by directing school administrators to not pressure or try to convince parents to have their child take the SBAC/CAA or other assessments; and
RESOLVED that SDEA call on SDUSD to direct administrators to not retaliate against educators who educate parents about their right to opt out their child from testing;
RESOLVED that SDEA will create a sample opt out letter, with translated versions, that can be shared with parents to enable parents to exercise their rights;
and be it finally RESOLVED that should the SDEA Representative Assembly pass this resolution, a copy of this resolution will be sent to the SDUSD School Board, the SDUSD Superintendent and SDEA members, posted on the SDEA website, and shared at CTA State Council and with parents and guardians during IEP meetings.