School Board Lays off 1534 Educators

Talks Like Deal Has Already Been Cut

Last night the School Board voted to issue 1534 educator layoffs, on top of the 1000 classified layoffs they’ve already issued, which will have the effect of turning our schools into human sardine factories. And Board President John Lee Evans has suggested that a side deal to “fix” it is possible.

First, let’s do the math together (since Board member and math teacher Kevin Beiser apparently still can’t):

  • $122 million = District’s worst case budget hole
  • $115 million = amount 1534 teacher layoffs alone will save
  • Tens of millions = amount 1000 classified layoffs will also save
  • $91 million =  total concessions the District asked for in exchange for no layoffs
  • $33 million = other cuts the District told the County they already have planned
  • $20 million = amount the District will save in attrition (conservative estimate)

We’re no Kevin Beiser, but if they only asked for $91 million from us in the first place, and they’ll get at least $20 million through attrition, then they could issue “only” about 900 teacher layoffs and still fill their entire worst case budget hole. That’s without the savings from classified layoffs (which are currently crippling our schools) and without taking a dime out of their reserves, which are over-padded by tens of millions according to County records. And remember, the worst case has never happened in the past.

That means a minimum of 600 people are about to get layoffs that everyone knows are unnecessary even in the worst case scenario, just to pressure us to open up our contract and give away the farm.

YOU CAN DO BETTER Richard Barrera, Kevin Beiser, John Lee Evans, and Shelia Jackson!

But just as worrisome is the way that John Lee Evans talked about what we can give up to fix their problem, and how. Evans talked about how the union could work a “side deal” without opening the contract. First of all, that’s not true. And secondly, that’s eerily similar to language used at last month’s SDEA Board retreat when CTA reviewed the District’s budget with the Board.

According to a CTA negotiations specialist at the SDEA Board retreat, the very act of even discussing a possible side letter about furlough days with the District is in and of itself negotiating. It doesn’t matter what the euphemism is – “side letter” or “modification” or “narrow scope of negotiations” – you cannot do it without opening our wage article because that’s where the furlough days are (Article 7). Once we engage in conversations with the District about changing current sections of the contract – which absolutely includes extending the furlough days and taking the associated pay decrease – we have opened the contract, which means the District can impose their “last best offer” on us, and we couldn’t even strike in protest because we have a no-strike clause during the term of the contract (Article 20).

There is simply no way to renegotiate furlough, raise deferrals, or healthcare modifications for next year without opening our contract. Any negotiations = open contract. Period.

John Lee Evans also said that mid-June is the deadline to finalize that deal in order to avoid layoffs. That’s just ridiculous. The state budget doesn’t even come out until June 30. The School Board can recall layoffs any time they want, just like they have every year since 2008. The only reason the District wants to cut a deal now is to have it in place before the budget comes out, in case it brings them better news and weakens their bargaining position.

Where is SDEA President Bill Freeman in all of this? He wasn’t at the Board meeting last night. He was in Sacramento with CTA, lobbying state legislators instead. Lobbying state politicians is fine, but not instead of putting pressure on our local politicians on the night they are voting to destroy thousands of lives. We need our union leadership here fighting tooth and nail against the layoffs. SDEA has yet to say a word about this today and we need a straight answer on this question – is the SDEA leadership considering giving up furlough days or in any other way opening our contract this summer? Because John Lee Evans sure seems to think we are.

We’ve done the math; now let’s look at the history. Last year, the School Board finalized only 800 of their original 1350 layoffs – a little more than half. That’s because last year we’d had 39 rallies with 7000-plus participants by the time they voted. This year, they finalized 1534 out of 1655 – more than 90 percent. That’s because our union’s organizing efforts have been lackluster, and our union president has been telling the District “we won’t let them go off a cliff” which is just another way of saying we’ll concede when it’s time. That’s why the Board is issuing hundreds of layoffs they know they don’t need. They know if they keep the pressure on, we’ll open our contract, call it a “side-deal” to make it more politically palatable, and they’ll be able to have a contract grab-fest.

It does not need to be this way! What can we do about it?

  1. Call an emergency union meeting at your school (we’ll be sending out suggested meeting materials).
  2. Get organized and get vocal NOW.
  3. Hold the District accountable.
  4. Hold the Union accountable: SDEA Board Contact.
  5. Stay in touch this summer.

3 thoughts on “School Board Lays off 1534 Educators

  1. Its all fine and dandy you have presented all this but what it comes down to it why don’t we ask the teachers to vote if they want concessions or not. Its great to fight for everything but come June 30th I have nothing. Who’s gonna pay my bills? I think that its up to teachers what we want done and not up to the union. I pay them $1200 a year and this is what I get!!

    • Lynn, not that this helps, but I’m in the same boat as you. I feel your pain. You should send an email to the SDEA president asking him if the teachers can vote on it. And please “cc” it to the other leaders there. Their contact link is on this page.

  2. Friends and Colleagues who have just read this, I’m urging you to stay in contact this summer. I know that you might be feeling down and even helpless, but we can beat the district. It’s going to take a magnanimous collective effort on our part to see this thing through. Try to imagine the exponential change that we can make as a result of our effort. It will be in the history tablets for future generations to reference.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s